On a suburban street in Perth, amid the pre-war homes and the peppermint trees, evidence of Australia’s transforming energy system is all around.
Almost every second property has solar panels bolted to the roof, pumping out electricity as the bright West Australian sun rides high in the midday sky.
Among them is the house owned by Alan Benn, a retired electronics engineer.
Mr Benn bought his first rooftop solar panels 20 years ago, when the systems were small – and expensive.
“The actual total cost of the solar power system at that time was about $19,000,” Mr Benn said.
“The $8,000 [subsidy] brought it down so my expense was $11,000.
“And that was just for a 1.5 kilowatt system, which is about a third of the size of what people buy nowadays … and they pay $5,000 for it.”
Officially, according to the Clean Energy Regulator, there were 507,862 solar installations on WA homes and businesses as of June 30.
Less officially, the regulator believes about one in every three WA households has a system.
Nationally, almost four million households and businesses have solar panels.
The continued rise of rooftop solar across the country has been a remarkable success story, with Australia the clear global leader in the adoption of the technology.
But in WA – home to the world’s biggest isolated or “island” grid in the south western corner of the state – the uptake of solar also poses some thorny questions.
What happens when you have so much solar power that it threatens to overload the grid at certain times?
And how much more difficult is it to manage that problem when your electricity system is all alone and doesn’t have anyone to bail it out?
Kate Ryan runs the WA arm of the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO), which is responsible for keeping the lights on in the country’s main electricity systems.
She said WA’s isolation meant it was having to find answers to those questions much sooner than almost anywhere else in the world.
“We don’t have the ability to borrow from our neighbours, or indeed, to give them the benefit of our excess supply at times when we have it,” Ms Ryan said.
Tony Wood, the energy program director at the Grattan Institute, said South Australia was often held up as the poster child of the renewable energy transition.
Mr Wood said about 75 per cent of South Australia’s power came from green sources such as wind and solar, which sometimes accounted for all its needs – and more.
It’s a similar story around the world from Asia to Europe and North America, where grids are meshed together to allow electricity trading and provide greater resilience.
But Mr Wood said WA was, in many ways, a more fascinating example of the transition because of its isolation.
“South Australia is getting to the point where on average it’s 100 per cent renewable,” he said.
“But that means sometimes it’s 200 per cent and sometimes it’s almost nothing.
“Now, that’s an example of the benefit of being connected to a larger grid, which of course Western Australia doesn’t have.”
Ms Ryan said solar power was a “tremendous” opportunity for the energy system because it was so cheap and Australia was so sunny.
But she acknowledged in WA “it comes with challenges, like when the cloud cover comes over, and might very quickly reduce the amount of rooftop solar being generated”.
“That means, as the grid operator, we need to find other sources of supply to meet that,” she said.
“And we’ve got to find that locally within our grid.”
For Ms Ryan, a big part of the answer was simple enough – storage.
“I think storage of electricity is really the silver bullet, I guess, the way that we harness that opportunity,” she said.
“And that’s storage at all levels.”
To that end, WA was making big bets on large-scale storage.
State-owned utility Synergy already has a 100MW “big battery” with 200MW/h of capacity and a second, much bigger battery with 800MW/h of capacity is under construction next door.
Meanwhile, private companies led by French renewable energy player Neoen are building a raft of massive batteries.
These include a 560 megawatt installation with a whopping 2240 mw per hour of capacity near Collie, a town south of Perth that is the traditional home of WA’s coal power industry.
But there are calls for smaller batteries to help soak up the excess solar power in the middle of the day.
There are “community” batteries that tended to be medium-sized, built by the network poles-and-wires companies and could act like banks, storing solar excess power for times it was needed.
And then there were small batteries at the household level.
Mr Wood said the uptake of solar across Australia was running ahead of the measures needed to manage the resource properly.
He said it was particularly acute in WA.
“Western Australia, on the one hand, has got a fantastic solar resource,” Mr Wood said.
“But making use of that in a way that can maintain the stability of the grid and provide reliable and affordable electricity to all Western Australians is going to be part of the challenge.”
According to Mr Wood, storage was also key to avoiding the kinds of drastic measures that AEMO currently has at its disposal.
While load shedding – or rolling blackouts – was the most extreme of these, he said others were almost as unpopular with solar households.
Chief among them was so-called curtailment, where the market operator effectively blocked a customer’s ability to export surplus solar generation from their panels.
In doing so, AEMO avoided the system being overloaded with too much solar power.
“If we don’t get on top of the challenges we have right now, the worst case would be to basically turn off your capacity to export your electricity to the grid,” Mr Wood said.
“And AEMO has always to be prepared to do this just in case because their job is to manage potential risks to the system.”
Clean Energy Regulator figures show WA lags in the uptake of household batteries.
As of June 30, barely 10,000 small-scale batteries had been installed in WA, compared with more than 20,000 in each of New South Wales, South Australia and Victoria.
WA Energy Minister Reece Whitby indicated the state government was looking at whether it should subsidise household batteries, but stopped short of making a commitment.
Mr Whitby said batteries were still relatively expensive, and would be unaffordable for many people even with the subsidies.
“Not everyone can put their own money up-front and be part of a rebate scheme, the types that exist in other states,” he said.
Ms Ryan said the rise of small-scale batteries – whether in the form of wall-mounted household units or in electric vehicles – seemed all but inevitable.
She said harnessing the capacity of those batteries along with the potential of solar panels and smart appliances that could be controlled remotely would be vital to the smooth operation of the grid.
“That can save us having to invest in quite significant amounts of large-scale generation that would also be able to meet that need,” she said.
“If we can effectively harness these consumer energy resources, so batteries and solar PV, that could have a benefit to the system of about half a billion dollars [in WA] over the next decade.
“For the national electricity market, effective coordination of these consumer energy resources could save literally billions of dollars of investment in large-scale infrastructure in our system.”
Perth householder Alan Benn, for his part, has already taken the next steps.
About 10 years ago, he bought an electric vehicle, while more recently he forked out for a home battery system that could meet practically all his power needs overnight.
The battery, which holds 10 kilowatt hours of storage, didn’t come cheap – Mr Benn said it cost him $12,500 and would arguably not save him money in net terms.
But he argued the investment still made sense at a personal and a system level given it would allow him to use much more of its own solar power.
He said it would enable him to reduce – or even eliminate – his contribution to the peak in demand which did so much to drive up costs.
“The more people that have batteries, the more we can cut down that peak just by storing our solar power and running the batteries through the evening,” Mr Benn said.
Loading