Australian News Today

‘The system is broken’: Hundreds of students, parents and teachers told us their thoughts about education

‘The system is broken’: Hundreds of students, parents and teachers told us their thoughts about education

Hundreds of students, parents and teachers shared their thoughts about the education system with us — this is what they said. 

A graphics showing a map of Australia.

Earlier this year Australians from all across the country responded to an audience call out embedded in a story about tutoring, inviting them to share their experiences with the education system.

A graphic showing education themes of mental health, funding, technology, social concerns and the future.

While there were hundreds of different views and voices, there were also many recurring themes, highlighting how various issues impact students, teachers and parents differently.

A graphic showing education themes of mental health, funding, technology, social concerns and the future.

Audience leads help inform our coverage, but we also wanted to share some of the responses back with readers, as they were often insightful, spoke to different sides of the same issue, or came from a voice not always included in the conversation.

A graphic showing the key themes highlighted, as well as if they were from a student, parent or teacher.

As you scroll through the quotes below, the map and demographic panels displayed will highlight whether the view is from a student, parent or teacher, as well as their topic of concern.

A graphics showing a map of Australia.

Please note: Some names have been changed due to privacy concerns and fears of being impacted for speaking openly, and some responses have been edited or paraphrased for clarity.

A graphic highlighting that the audience member is a teacher in WA, and their concern is about mental health.

“The entire system is broken. It requires kids to be square pegs that fit in square holes despite huge class sizes, an array of individual needs, and goal posts that keep shifting. It’s set-up to fail.” 

Sarah, teacher, WA

A graphic highlighting that the audience member is a parent in NSW concerned about mental health.

“Bullying is a massive problem compounded by perpetrators that make themselves out to be victims, resulting in a loss of trust in the system [and] suicidal thoughts, especially in high school.” 

Jenna, parent, NSW

A graphic highlighting that the audience member is a student in QLD, and their concern is about mental health.

“Everyone is suffering with mental health. I’m certainly not the only one. But instead of support, everything gets blamed on crime, values, behaviour … we’re just kids! We need help, not analysis.” 

Marissa, student, QLD

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a teacher in NSW concerned about mental health.

“Teacher mental health is critical but often overlooked. When educators are pushed to breaking point the ability to inspire diminishes. It doesn’t just harm them, but the students who rely on them.” 

Kellie, teacher, NSW

A graphic highlighting that the audience member is a parent in ACT concerned about funding.

“I’m concerned about rising inequality and ‘class divides’ caused by funding gaps between private and public. Finland, Norway, Germany have fixed this problem. Why can’t we?” 

Elizabeth, parent, ACT

A graphic highlighting that the audience member is a student in Tasmania concerned about funding.

“The decline of public education as private schools hoard funding is concerning. Students are struggling, performance is declining, and insufficient public transport is another obstacle.” 

Luke, student, TAS 

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a teacher in NSW concerned about funding.

“The government is failing kids with the lack of resources and funding. The curriculum, syllabus, support services … they’re not up to scratch. It’s a joke, to the point I’ve begun thinking of leaving teaching.” 

Alex, teacher, NSW

A graphic showing that the following audience member is a parent in South Australia, concerned about funding.

“I’ve started home schooling due to neglect in public education. Many ambitious kids disengage as there’s no incentive to excel while inflexible classes can’t tailor to individual needs.” 

Jaimi, parent, SA

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a parent in Victoria concerned about technology.

“As the world changes rapidly, so do our needs. With the internet and the constant exchange of (mis)information, I wonder if what [schools] offer will stay relevant in the future. I don’t think we’re fully prepared.”

Dicle, parent, VIC

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a student in Tasmania concerned about AI and technology.

“AI is increasingly a problem. Despite the rules, so much work is done with AI. I don’t agree, but don’t know what can be done. It’s impossible to track and tackle properly.” 

Jessica, student, TAS

A graphic highlighting the following audience member is a teacher in NT concerned about technology.

“Families with limited access to technology at home want it taught more, while households that live online want it banned. Responsible use just gets handballed to the school.” 

Roger, teacher, NT

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a parent in Queensland concerned about technology.

“There’s too much reliance on iPads and computers at school. My children’s book list just contained a list of apps — that’s it — and did not require use of pens or paper.” 

Elia, parent, QLD

A graphic showing a map of Australia with a question mark inviting audiences to write in.

Do you have an education story or experience you’d like to share? Get in touch via the form at the end of this story.

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a parent in Queensland with social and cultural concerns.

“The crucial factor left out of the conversation is what happens at home. Discipline, curiosity — these things start at home. Without that, schools will be ineffective no matter what.” 

Liat, parent, QLD

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a teacher in Tasmania with social and cultural concerns.

“The school structure hasn’t changed in decades, but the world has. Instead of adapting, we increase subjects, spread hours thin, cut resources, then complain. It’s unsustainable.” 

Gayle, teacher, TAS

A graphic highlighting the following audience member is a student in WA concerned about social issues.

“The system is failing. Curriculums aren’t fit for the future. And managing behaviour — often violent or harmful, targeting Indigenous people or immigrants; not to mention drugs and alcohol — is a huge problem.” 

Pippa, student, WA 

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a teacher in Victoria concerned about social issues.

“The pressure parents place on kids, trying to influence class, is concerning. Young tutors can’t push back, and kids are often valued by how much they study. It’s disempowering, during a vulnerable period of life.” 

Shirlaine, tutor, VIC

A graphic highlighting that the following audience member is a student in WA concerned about the future.

“I don’t know what to do, my grades dropped a bit and I feel like unless I keep them up I won’t make it in life. I don’t know what happened. I was doing well but now I question my ability to go on.” 

Tanya, student, WA

A graphic highlighting that the audience member is a teacher in NT concerned about the future.

“Kids are burnt out before they even reach the workforce. And instead of [really educating them], schools are just designed to secure funds and university placements. The rest are left behind.” 

Nicole, teacher, NT

A graphic highlighting that the audience member is a parent in Victoria concerned about the future.

“As the world changes rapidly, so do our needs. But we can’t be required to pay a fortune to send kids to a proper school to meet those needs. This will break the community in future.” 

Louise, parent, VIC

A graphic showing the audience member is a former teacher in the ACT concerned about jobs and the future.

“Teaching is a career cul-de-sac. No reward to excel. If you do excel, or try to speak out, they pressure you, and they’re unionised to the core. The best teachers leave and never look back.” 

Peter, former teacher, ACT

A graphic showing a map of Australia with a lightbulb and the word "solutions".

While many responses acknowledged that education issues were multifaceted and required complex solutions, others volunteered some quick thoughts and ideas about what they would like to see done.

AI bans in schools, voting rights for minors, smaller class sizes, online learning for remote communities and more student involvement in future planning were among the solutions explored, some of which we are covering in more depth in other stories.

Many were eager to take the first step towards change, while others were unsure how or felt powerless either due to being underage, or fearful of a backlash from employers, schools, parents or the community.

What are your thoughts?

If you would like to read more of the ABC’s education coverage or related stories impacting communities, you can head to the ABC’s Education Homepage or click on the links from the selection below: